So I’m working on my Pirates story, and chatting with my beta, and decide to go glance in the Pit to see what’s passing for original Pirates fan fic lately…
In FOUR pages of stories, I found ONE that looked readable. This saddens me. I tend to scan summaries for certain words, looking for warning signs. Certain words come with big, blaring sirens and red lights flashing.
KnifeEdge’s List of Summary Keywords to Avoid At All Costs:
- Self insertion
- OC/anyone
- “daughter”
- modern
- sucked into TV/Movie/Hollywood
- transported into the future/past
- me and my friends
That weeds out about 98% of the stories in the Pit, not leaving very much.
Let’s take a look at some of the more recent summaries in the Pit. I’m not linking to the stories, or including the titles. I just want to examine why some summaries work, and some really DON’T.
This is yet another insert fic. I get sucked into the world of POTC Curse of the Black Pearl. How will the story change when I’m in it? COMPLETE!
Okay, first of all… who are you? Why are you so interesting that you think I’d want to read a story about you? Why would I want to read a story where you change the whole plot to fit yourself in, when I liked the plot very much as it was? This is the kind of story I pretty much put a great big red X over when skimming. I had a creative writing teacher in college who gave us a lecture on Why You Shouldn’t Write Yourself Into Your Stories (unless they’re non-fiction, first person, of course). For one thing, he said, the temptation to make yourself better than you are is always there, which makes your character unbelievable. No one wants to write themselves in a bad light. Second, you’re boring. No one but your friends and family know you, nor do they care about you. Why would other people want to read a story about you?
That’s right! Your fav Pirate buddy’s are going to Holloywood to cook up some more trouble. The Pirates take their first plane ride, Elizabeth blow’s up a shop and Norrington knocks down the famous Hollywood sign! Plus much more! Ch 4 now up!
I count four spelling/grammar mistakes in a three line summary. That doesn’t bode well for the rest of the story, and yes, I’m picky about spelling. Second… so… we’ve ditched plot, canon, and character, distilled it all down to some broad brush strokes, and added a wacky sort of plot line. Let me leap right on that one… Don’t get me wrong, parody in the right hands can be a fun experience, but this doesn’t read like parody so much as someone playing with Jack Sparrow action figures.
AWE Spoilers! At the Brethren Court Meeting Jack is reunited with his father. It’s the first time he’s seen him in years. But who’s to say that his father won’t be the only one he’s reuniting with in several years? And what would make Jack Sparrow cry?
Okay, this one is a bit better. Slightly interesting premise. However, my suethor detector is pinging. “But who’s to say that his father won’t be the only one he’s reuniting with in several years?”… hmmm. That implies that there is a character that Jack knew a long time ago that’s going to miraculously turn up. And that this someone is probably going to make Jack cry. You know, maybe it’s me, but I can’t picture Jack crying over much. Possibly his ship being blown up, or dropping a canon ball on his foot and accompanying it with a lot of swearing. Jack, however, seems to be pretty resilient. Why waste time crying over something when you could be figuring out a way to turn it to your own profit? I think I’ll pass over weepy Jack.
Jack finds a misfit in a whorehouse. Tell me if I should continue, and hurt me if it starts turning into a marysue. JackxOC
Right. I haven’t even read it and I’m already looking for sharp objects. If you picked up a book and it had this on the back cover, would YOU read it? I don’t usually start reading something if the author makes it a point to tell me it’s likely to go bad.
A looting mistake lands a young woman aboard the Black Pearl. She believes herself to be a prisoner to its captain but little does she know that she has imprisoned something in him, his heart. JOC WE I apologize for the crappy title
Again with the apologies… Also, the Cliche-o-meter is rating this plot summary at Horse Beaten to Pudding level.
Set directly after DMC and continuing through AWE: Barbossa is back and needs the help of an old flame, to fix things. BarbossaOC
Okay, I’ll give this one points for originality. However, it looses points for squick factor. Did you SEE At World’s End? Barbossa’s idea of romance involves bellowing at his “love” like a bad Shakespearean actor. I think I’ll pass…
A oneshot paying homage to a brave soul, a boy with dreams and hopes. This fanfiction is concerned with the cabin boy hung at the beginning of At World’s End and why it was he faced that fate.
Finally, a decent summary. Could be tightened up a bit, but it’s clearly got an original plotline, it’s spelled correctly, no apologies. Good job. I actually read this one, and enjoyed it very much.
Summaries, I’ve learned about through trial and error. My first few summaries sucked nearly as bad as some of these–and I wince whenever I have to read them. Your summary is what sells your story. Even though fan fic is written for fun, you still want people to read it, right? So don’t sabotage it before they’ve even clicked on the link.
Tips for a good summary:
- Give people a real taste of what your story is about. Think about book summaries on Amazon, or book jackets. Think about how they’re worded, the kind of information they include. Use that as your template. Or think about movie trailers “In a world where…” Okay, maybe not THAT cliche.
- Don’t apologize. For anything. Really. I’m not going to read something if you feel you need to apologize for it.
- Check your spelling. Check your grammar. It’s highly indicative of how the rest of your writing is going to go.
- If you can’t think up a good summary have your beta reader write one for you. Often they’re good at pinpointing what a story is really about, because they’re not as close to it as you are.
- If you STILL can’t think of a good summary: give us an excerpt from the first part of your story. Something that will hook the reader and make them want to know what happens next.
- Above all: don’t write crappy stories. Really. It’ll improve the quality of your summary if your story doesn’t suck.
As always, remember: advice should be taken with a large amount of salt.